The world of NHL contracts is a fascinating one, often leaving fans and analysts alike scratching their heads. With the 2026-27 season approaching, let's dive into some of the most intriguing and, dare I say, questionable deals that have been inked.
The Top 10 Worst NHL Contracts for 2026-27
10. Jordan Binnington, St. Louis Blues
Starting our countdown, we have Jordan Binnington's six-year extension with the Blues. While he has a Stanley Cup under his belt, his performance hasn't quite lived up to the contract's expectations. The trade rumors surrounding him highlight the uncertainty of his future, and his temperamental play adds an interesting layer to this deal.
My Take: It's a fine line between rewarding past achievements and overpaying for potential. Binnington's case is a classic example of this dilemma.
9. Timo Meier, New Jersey Devils
Timo Meier's eight-year deal with the Devils is an intriguing one. With a hefty cap hit, the expectations for his offensive output are high. However, his consistent but not spectacular performance leaves room for debate.
Personal Perspective: Consistency is key, but in a league where goals and points are celebrated, Meier's contract might be a reminder that sometimes, the eye test doesn't always align with the stats.
8. Jacob Trouba, San Jose Sharks
The Sharks' decision to sign Jacob Trouba for four years and $33 million raises some eyebrows. Known for his physical style, Trouba's age and the high price tag make this deal a risky move.
What Many Don't Realize: Trouba's leadership and defensive skills might be worth the investment for a young team like the Sharks, but the long-term implications could be a concern.
7. J.T. Miller, New York Rangers
J.T. Miller's return to the Rangers comes with a hefty price tag and the expectation of leading the team. His past success with the Canucks might be a tough act to follow, especially at his age.
In My Opinion: Miller's ability to adapt and maintain his edge will be crucial. The Rangers are banking on his leadership, but can he deliver consistently?
6. Kirill Kaprizov, Minnesota Wild
Kaprizov's eight-year, $136 million contract is a significant commitment. His goal-scoring prowess is undeniable, but the contract's value is a topic of discussion.
A Deeper Look: Kaprizov's talent is rare, but the Wild's decision to secure him long-term might impact their flexibility in other areas. It's a high-risk, high-reward strategy.
5. Darnell Nurse, San Jose Sharks
Nurse's deal with the Sharks, originally signed with the Oilers, is an interesting addition to this list. His defensive skills and two-way play haven't quite justified the high salary.
Reflection: Sometimes, the market value and a player's actual worth don't align. Nurse's contract might be a reminder of the challenges of evaluating players in a league as dynamic as the NHL.
4. Jonathan Huberdeau, Calgary Flames
Huberdeau's eight-year contract with the Flames is a curious one. His performance hasn't matched the expectations set by his high cap hit.
What This Really Suggests: The Flames might have overestimated Huberdeau's impact, and now they're left with a contract that doesn't quite fit their current needs.
3. Elias Pettersson, Vancouver Canucks
Pettersson's decline in recent seasons is a sad story. His high cap hit and reduced production make him a challenging asset to trade.
A Detail That I Find Interesting: Pettersson's situation highlights the fine line between a player's potential and their actual performance. It's a reminder that sometimes, expectations can be a heavy burden.
2. Bowen Byram, Chicago Blackhawks
Byram's six-year extension with the Blackhawks is a shock to the system. His high cap hit sets a new standard for defensemen, and the pressure is on to deliver.
If You Take a Step Back: Byram's contract is a bold move by the Blackhawks, but it also raises questions about the long-term strategy and the team's ability to build a competitive roster.
1. Leo Carlsson, Anaheim Ducks
Carlsson's new deal with the Ducks, matched from the Flyers' offer sheet, is a game-changer. It sets a new precedent for young players' negotiations and the threat of offer sheets.
The Bigger Picture: Carlsson's contract might revolutionize the way young stars approach their careers, but it also puts immense pressure on him to perform at an elite level consistently.
As we reflect on these contracts, it's clear that the NHL's financial landscape is complex and often unpredictable. These deals offer a glimpse into the challenges and strategies teams employ, and the impact they can have on the league's future.
